Cartus vs SIRVA BGRS vs Graebel: Which Relocation Partner Fits Your Program?
Cartus, SIRVA BGRS and Graebel all claim global reach. They differ in how they charge, who does the work on the ground and how much attention a smaller client gets. Here's which one fits your move volume.
The choice comes down to who does the work in each country
If you run 15 international moves a year, you need something different from a company running 1,500, even though both will shortlist the same three names. Cartus, SIRVA BGRS and Graebel are the relocation management companies (RMCs) that show up on almost every enterprise RFP. Each can coordinate a family's move from Bengaluru to Berlin or from São Paulo to Singapore. They don't do that work the same way, and they don't charge for it the same way.
A cartus vs sirva evaluation, with Graebel as the third option, usually turns on four questions:
- Supplier network: In the countries you move people to most, who does the destination services, immigration support, temporary housing and household goods shipping? The RMC's own staff, a preferred partner, or a subcontractor two steps removed?
- Fee model: How much of the RMC's revenue comes from your management fees, and how much from supplier referral fees, markups and rebates you never see on an invoice?
- Technology: Does the platform give your HR team live cost and status data, and does it connect to your HRIS and payroll so relocation benefits are reported for tax correctly?
- Account service: At your volume, who picks up the phone, and how often does that person change?
This comparison works through each question and ends with a verdict for low-volume, mid-size and enterprise programs. It draws on public information and on how the RMC market generally works, not on hands-on testing. Vendor capabilities change, so verify every claim here in your own RFP.
Ownership and operating models behind the three brands
Ownership matters more than most buyers assume. It shapes how each RMC makes money, how fast it invests in technology and how stable your account team is likely to be.
Cartus
Cartus is one of the oldest and largest RMCs, and it has long been owned by a residential real estate group. That history explains its traditional strength in domestic homeowner relocation: home sale programs, broker networks and mortgage coordination. It also runs a long-standing global operation with service centers in several regions, and it invests in policy benchmarking and consulting. Corporate ownership in the real estate sector has shifted in recent years, so ask directly whether any ownership change affects contracts, systems or staffing.
SIRVA BGRS
SIRVA BGRS combines two businesses. SIRVA has historically owned household goods moving brands, including Allied and northAmerican. BGRS (formerly Brookfield Global Relocation Services) brought a large corporate and government relocation book with deep roots in Canada. The result is unusual: an RMC with its own moving capacity in some markets. The company has been through financial restructuring in recent years. That doesn't rule it out, but you should run a current financial review during procurement, as you would for any critical supplier.
Graebel
Graebel is privately held and family-founded, with headquarters in Colorado. By most public measures it's smaller than the other two. It sells itself on service consistency, a more consultative account model and willingness to customize. Like the others, it runs a global network that mixes owned operations with partners.
The practical upshot: Cartus and SIRVA BGRS compete on scale and breadth, while Graebel competes on attention. Which you need depends heavily on your volume.
Regional supplier networks beyond headline country counts
All three claim coverage in well over 100 countries, so the country count tells you nothing. What matters is how much of the work in each country is done by people the RMC directly manages, and how much passes through one or more subcontracting layers.
In general, the regional picture looks like this for all three:
- North America and Western Europe: The deepest supplier bench. Expect dense destination service provider (DSP) networks, multiple vetted movers and competitive temporary housing. Home sale and home purchase programs are mostly a US and Canada product. In the UK, continental Europe and most of Asia, the work leans toward rental search, lease negotiation and tenancy management.
- India and Southeast Asia: Coverage in Bengaluru, Mumbai, Singapore, Kuala Lumpur and Manila is generally solid. School search and settling-in quality varies more from one DSP to the next. Immigration support is often handled by an affiliated law firm rather than the RMC, which matters when timelines are tight.
- Middle East: In the Gulf states, housing is often tied to employer allowances or company-leased properties, and visa sponsorship rules determine sequencing. Check whether the RMC has its own people in Dubai or Riyadh or relies entirely on partners.
- Latin America and Africa: The biggest gap between the marketing map and what happens on the ground. Moves to Lagos, Nairobi, Bogotá or Lima often run through a single local partner. Ask how many DSPs the RMC uses in each of your top five cities here, and what the backup is if that partner fails.
As a rough pattern, SIRVA BGRS's own moving assets may give it more control over household goods where it operates them. Cartus's large client base tends to give it volume leverage with DSPs in major hubs. Graebel's smaller scale likely means it relies on partners in more places, though it says it manages them closely. None of these is automatically better. The right choice depends on where your moves go.
What to do about it: Pull your last two years of move data and list your top ten origin-destination pairs. Ask each RMC to name the supplier it would use on each leg, with that supplier's service scores for the past 12 months. An RMC that can't answer at that level has told you something.
Fee models and the cost drivers buyers miss
The fee model is where an RMC comparison usually gets misleading. The management fee in the proposal is often the smallest part of the RMC's economics.
All three use some mix of the elements below. The figures are indicative 2026 market ranges in USD. They vary by contract, volume, region and policy tier, so confirm current pricing with each vendor.
| Fee element | How it works | Indicative range (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Per-file management fee, full-service domestic move | Charged at initiation; covers coordination and expense management | Roughly $1,500–$4,500 per file |
| Per-file management fee, international long-term assignment | Higher because it covers immigration coordination, host-country compliance and repatriation | Roughly $3,000–$8,000+ per file |
| Lump-sum administration fee | For employees who get a cash allowance with light-touch support | Roughly $300–$1,200 per file |
| Supplier referral fees and rebates | Paid to the RMC by brokers, movers or housing providers; often not visible to the client | Highly variable. Ask for disclosure |
| Supplier markups | A margin added to pass-through costs such as temporary housing or DSP services | Varies widely where applied |
| Tax gross-up and compliance reporting | Calculating and reporting taxable relocation benefits through payroll | Often bundled; sometimes charged per file |
Some RMCs offer low or even zero management fees and earn their margin from supplier referral fees. That's legal and common, particularly in US home sale programs. But it creates an incentive to steer moves toward suppliers who pay the RMC. Others offer a transparent or net model: a higher management fee in exchange for passing through supplier rebates or crediting them back to you.
A hypothetical worked example. Say a 600-person company moves 30 people a year: 10 international assignments, 15 regional transfers within Europe or Asia, and 5 lump-sum moves. On a transparent model at mid-range fees, that's about 10 × $5,000 + 15 × $2,500 + 5 × $600 = $90,500 a year in management fees. Those fees sit on top of perhaps $1.2–2.5 million in actual move costs. A 5% saving on supplier costs, from better negotiation or less markup, is worth $60,000–$125,000. That's comparable to, or larger than, the whole management fee. So negotiate supplier pricing and rebate disclosure first and the headline fee second.
The biggest cost drivers outside the RMC's fee are temporary housing length, household goods volume and shipping mode (sea versus air), tax gross-up policy, and the length of school and home search. Your policy design controls these, not the vendor.
Technology: assignee apps, client reporting and payroll handoffs
All three RMCs offer an employee-facing app or portal for move tracking, expense submission and document upload. All three give clients a dashboard showing pipeline, spend against budget and survey scores. At demo level they look much alike. The differences show up in three places.
Payroll and tax data flow
In most countries, relocation benefits are taxable or reportable in some form. Examples include UK benefit-in-kind reporting, perquisite taxation in India, and social security questions across the EU. The RMC has to send accurate, timely benefit data to each payroll you run. Ask for a sample file format, how often it's sent and how corrections are handled. If you use an employer of record or several in-country payroll providers, ask how the RMC delivers data to third parties it doesn't control. This handoff fails more often than any other step in relocation.
HRIS integration
Large clients can expect API or flat-file connections to the major HRIS platforms, so move initiation starts from an approved transfer rather than a manual email. Check whether the integration is standard or a paid custom build, and who maintains it when either system changes.
Data protection
Relocation files hold passports, family details, salary and sometimes medical information. The RMC must meet GDPR for EU and UK data, India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act where it applies, and transfer rules in markets such as Brazil, South Africa, Saudi Arabia and China. Ask where data is hosted, which subprocessors (including DSPs) receive personal data, and how cross-border transfers are documented. Have privacy counsel review the data processing agreement. Don't treat it as boilerplate.
Given their scale, Cartus and SIRVA BGRS likely invest more in analytics and benchmarking, and Graebel is often positioned as easier to customize for mid-size clients. Treat both as claims to test. Ask each vendor for a sandbox login and try it on your own reporting questions.
Account service at your volume
Account service is the most important factor in RMC performance and the one that varies most within a single vendor. Your experience depends far more on the team assigned to you than on the brand.
Large RMCs typically organize service in tiers:
- Enterprise accounts (hundreds of moves a year) get a dedicated client account manager, named move consultants, quarterly business reviews and often a senior sponsor.
- Mid-size accounts get a named account manager who also covers other clients, plus a pooled consultant team.
- Small accounts often go to a shared service center, where consultants rotate and the account manager handles a large portfolio.
Graebel's pitch is that the gap between those tiers is smaller, so a mid-size client gets something closer to an enterprise experience. That fits its size and positioning, but the only way to confirm it is to interview the proposed team and call references of similar size. Cartus and SIRVA BGRS can both deliver excellent dedicated service to large accounts. A program with 20 moves a year should assume a pooled model unless the contract says otherwise.
Put these in the contract, not just the proposal:
- The named account manager, and a maximum client portfolio for that person
- Response-time service levels for employees and for HR, measured and reported monthly
- Time-zone coverage for your main regions, with escalation paths for Asia-Pacific and Middle East moves outside North American or European business hours
- Notice and handover requirements if your account manager changes
Red flags in proposals and an RFP checklist
Watch for these during evaluation:
- Zero management fee with no rebate disclosure. The money is coming from somewhere.
- Country coverage claims with no named suppliers for your top destinations.
- References that don't match your size. A reference from a 2,000-move client tells a 30-move client very little.
- Different sales and implementation teams, with the implementation team never introduced.
- Vague answers on payroll handoff, especially if you use several payroll providers or an EOR.
- Auto-renewing contracts with no service-level reporting and no right to exit for repeated misses.
A short RFP that actually separates the three:
- Share anonymized move data covering volumes, routes and policy tiers, so pricing reflects your real mix.
- Ask for itemized pricing per policy tier and full disclosure of supplier compensation.
- Ask for named suppliers and 12-month service scores for your top ten routes.
- Ask for the payroll data file specification and a sample tax reporting output for two of your host countries.
- Interview the proposed account manager and lead consultant.
- Call two references at your volume and one in your hardest region.
- Have legal and finance sign off on the data processing agreement and the financial stability review.
Relocation policy touches immigration, employment and tax law in every country involved. Have qualified immigration counsel and a cross-border tax adviser review your policy and the RMC's processes. Don't rely on the RMC's own interpretation.
Verdict for low-volume, mid-size and enterprise programs
None of these three is the best relocation management company for every buyer. Volume and route mix decide it.
| Program profile | Best fit | Why | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low-volume (under ~25 moves/year) | Graebel, or a smaller specialist | Most likely of the three to give a small client a named, stable team | Minimum fees, and whether the larger two will prioritize you at all |
| Mid-size (25–250 moves/year) | Graebel or Cartus | Graebel for high-touch service and customization; Cartus for broader benchmarking and hub coverage | A pooled service model at Cartus; thinner owned coverage in emerging markets at Graebel |
| Enterprise (250+ moves/year, multi-region) | Cartus or SIRVA BGRS | Scale, supplier leverage and analytics; SIRVA BGRS adds owned moving capacity in some markets | Rebate economics, financial due diligence, account team turnover |
Low-volume programs: For these buyers, the most useful answer to cartus vs sirva may be neither. The large RMCs are built for scale, and a company with a dozen moves a year often does better with Graebel or a smaller global relocation provider. Aires, Weichert Workforce Mobility, Crown World Mobility and Santa Fe Relocation are examples, and their regional strengths differ. If most of your moves are lump-sum, a lighter platform or a direct DSP arrangement may cost less than any full RMC.
Mid-size programs: Graebel is the one we'd test first, because account attention matters most at this size and Graebel is built around it. Choose Cartus instead if you need strong policy benchmarking or move heavily through major global hubs where its volume gives it pricing leverage.
Enterprise programs: For a multi-region enterprise, Cartus versus SIRVA BGRS is close to a coin flip on paper, so settle it with your route data. SIRVA BGRS makes sense when control over household goods matters and its own moving assets cover your lanes. Cartus makes sense when breadth of DSP coverage and consulting depth matter more. Either way, insist on full rebate transparency and a financial review.
Decision rule: Send all three the same anonymized route list and ask for named suppliers and itemized, rebate-disclosed pricing. Pick the vendor whose answers are most specific for your top five destinations, not the one with the lowest headline fee.
Common questions
Is Cartus or SIRVA BGRS cheaper?
Neither is consistently cheaper. Total cost depends on your policy mix, your routes and how supplier rebates are handled. A proposal with a lower management fee can cost more overall if the RMC earns its margin through supplier markups or referral fees. Compare full itemized pricing on your own move data, require rebate disclosure, and confirm current rates with each vendor.
Do I need a relocation management company if I only move a few people a year?
Not always. If you make fewer than about ten moves a year, mostly on lump-sum allowances, a direct arrangement with a destination services provider and an immigration firm can cost less. Once you have multi-country assignments, family moves or complex payroll tax reporting, an RMC's coordination and compliance work often pays for itself.
How long does it take to switch relocation providers?
Plan for several months. Transition covers contracting, policy configuration, HRIS and payroll integration testing, and supplier onboarding, and the timeline depends on how complex your setup is. Moves already in progress usually stay with the outgoing RMC until they finish, so budget for a period of running both. Set a cutover date for new initiations and agree on data transfer terms in advance.
What are supplier referral fees in relocation, and should I worry about them?
They're payments that real estate brokers, movers or housing providers make to the RMC for sending business their way. They're common and generally legal, but they can push supplier choice away from what's best for your employee or your budget. Ask for full disclosure and consider a model where rebates are credited back to you.
Can an RMC handle tax and immigration compliance for my relocations?
RMCs coordinate tax gross-ups, benefit reporting and visa processes, often through affiliated law firms and tax advisers. Legal responsibility for employment, payroll and immigration compliance stays with you as the employer, or with your employer of record if you use one. Have licensed immigration counsel and cross-border tax advisers review your relocation policy and how it's applied in each country.
Written by the Hire Team Plus editorial team. Prices, features and rules change often - confirm details with the vendor or a licensed professional before you decide.